Showing posts with label digital ministry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label digital ministry. Show all posts

Friday, 27 February 2009

Online Reptuation Management: REMO style

Some months ago in Digital Ministry I penned an article about Remo being one of the first Australian websites to build a community around ecommerce.

Recently in light of the Victorian bushfires Remo had a new t-shirt designed that was a fundraiser with all money going to the Victorian fire appeal. On the surface it looked like a no-brainer, good product idea married with an altruistic purpose (they'd done it before the the "Sorry" t-shirt). Technically it should have ticked all the boxes. But… it didn’t pan out that way.



What ensued was actually a good case-study of online crisis management.

So how did the crisis unfold?

STEP 1: The t-shirt went up on display with the offer that

“100% of the proceeds from the sale of this design will be donated by REMO on behalf of its CustOMERs to the Australian Red Cross Victorian Bushfire Appeal”


STEP 2: A range of positive and negative feedback from members occurred regarding the t-shirt with some members particularly upset about the original design (not shown here) that had a fire blaze and an unhappy face. Comments included:

"This is not an opportunity for SELF PROMOTION! You've lost me.... I won't be back! And please people, just donate direct to the Red Cross. That way all of your money goes direct to the recipients."

"Sorry, but I find this particularly bad taste. This is not a merchandising or marketing opportunity! Asking customers to donate directly to the Red Cross Appeal would be a far more appropriate response rather than celebrating it on a T-Shirt."

"The Black Saturday T-shirt design would have been somewhat more poignant with out the sad face. I mean really, that's obvious, and I think it just makes it a little tacky."


STEP.3. Remo to his credit followed the Crisis Management handbook to the letter. So what did he do?

a. He apologised – admitted there was a problem.



b. He responded quickly – in fact the same day

c. He responded to each individual with a personal message.



d. He listened. Members of the community particularly disliked the flame and unhappy face. He then had the t-shirt redesigned extremely quickly without these elements. Even some of those that were critical had turned around:

"Given my earlier suggestion to drop the :( and flame I must revise this up to 5 stars. But I still advocate direct donations..........and buy the tee-shirt too."



The events that happened online happened extremely quickly – online communities move fast.

What was also interesting apart from Remo’s control of the situation was the ability of an online community to self-regulate with some members coming to the defence of Remo saying:

"I don't think it's in bad taste, it is a way of showing support for those victims and whenever you wear the t-shirt will remind yourself and others of the support these victims need. It is no different than attending a football game whose proceeds go to the same benefit."


While the crisis occurred online what ensued showed that the old crisis management techniques still apply and are more important than ever.

Thanks to Jenni Beattie from The Digital Edge for this post.

Slice Media www.slicemedia.com media monitoring and tracking Australian & New Zealand TV press & radio Media monitoring

Wednesday, 26 March 2008

Think twice about your creative

A great post from Chris Brinkworth of Digital Ministry recently showed a raft of unfortunate ad placements on online news sites. While these get a giggle initially, it does make you start to think more carefully about designing ads for volatile online content environments.

Ad placement technology does have the ability to exclude online ads from pages containing certain keywords (a bit like using the 'NOT' command in a Slice search string), so why does it still happen? This is definitely an issue to raise with your media buyer or advertising sales person.

The reality is though, it is impossible to account for every possible scenario. Maintaining vigilence and having a handle on what stories are in the media (thanks Slice!) will help marketing managers turn off/suspend/replace ads until a more appropriate time or place.

And is there also a case for designing ads that are complementary or provocative for major news stories? Quick witted creatives and commitment to the cause would be needed to pull this off (recall: Nike's ads with Cathy Freeman that appeared the day after she won gold in 2000).

On the upside, an ad caught up in one of these scenarios is likely to get more attention, and maybe even become part of a viral campaign like the one Chris has created below... and as time passes, we can all look back and have a (politically incorrect) chuckle.

To see Chris' full online album of screen shots of unfortunate ad placements, click here.

Slice Media media www.slicemedia.com.au monitoring and tracking Australian & New Zealand TV press & radioTracking the media, monitoring the message